Scratch and Dent vs. Open Box vs. Refurbished: What's the Difference?

You’re shopping for a new refrigerator or washer and you keep seeing the same three labels: scratch and dent, open box, and refurbished. They all promise savings over full retail. They all sound vaguely similar. But they’re actually very different products with different histories, different warranties, and different risk profiles.

Understanding the distinctions can save you hundreds of dollars — or keep you from buying something you’ll regret. Here’s a clear breakdown of each category and how to decide which one is right for you.

Scratch and Dent: Brand New With Cosmetic Flaws

A scratch and dent appliance is a brand-new, never-used unit that sustained minor cosmetic damage during manufacturing, shipping, or warehouse handling. Think: a small dent on the side panel, a light scratch on the door, or a scuff on the top.

Inside, the unit is identical to the full-price version sitting in a showroom. Same compressor, same motor, same electronics, same everything. The only difference is a blemish on the exterior that prevents it from being sold as cosmetically perfect.

Typical savings: 30% to 70% off retail.

Warranty: Most scratch and dent appliances carry the full manufacturer’s warranty because they are, technically, new products.

Risk level: Low. You’re getting a new appliance. The only question is whether the cosmetic damage bothers you.

Best for: Budget-conscious shoppers who want new appliances with full warranties and don’t mind minor cosmetic imperfections.

Open Box: Returned After Purchase

An open-box appliance is a unit that was sold to a customer, delivered (or picked up), and then returned. The reasons for return vary widely: the customer changed their mind, ordered the wrong size, didn’t like the color, moved to a home with different hookups, or simply found a better deal elsewhere.

Some open-box units were literally never unboxed. Others were installed and used for a few days or weeks before being sent back. You don’t always know which scenario you’re getting, which is why inspection matters.

Typical savings: 15% to 30% off retail.

Warranty: This is where it gets complicated. Some retailers reset the manufacturer warranty from the date of your purchase. Others count the warranty as starting from the original buyer’s purchase date. And some sell open-box items as-is with no warranty at all.

Risk level: Low to moderate.

Best for: Shoppers who want near-new condition at a modest discount and are willing to ask questions about usage history and warranty terms.

Refurbished: Repaired and Restored

A refurbished appliance is a unit that had a functional problem, was repaired, tested, and put back on sale. This is the category that differs most significantly from the other two, because the appliance had something mechanically wrong with it at some point.

The quality of a refurbished appliance depends entirely on who did the refurbishing. A manufacturer-certified refurbishment is very different from a local repair shop slapping a new coat of paint on an old unit.

Typical savings: 40% to 60% off retail.

Warranty: Manufacturer-certified refurbished appliances often come with a limited warranty, typically 90 days to one year. Independent refurbishers may offer their own warranty or sell as-is.

Risk level: Moderate.

Best for: Shoppers on a tight budget who are comfortable with some risk, or those looking for a reliable secondary appliance.

The Comparison at a Glance

Condition: Scratch and dent units are new and unused with only cosmetic blemishes. Open-box units range from unused to lightly used. Refurbished units have been previously used or defective, then repaired.

Savings off retail: Scratch and dent delivers the deepest discounts at 30-70% off. Refurbished comes next at 40-60% off. Open box offers the smallest discount, typically 15-30% off.

Warranty coverage: Scratch and dent typically includes the full manufacturer warranty. Open-box warranties vary widely by retailer. Refurbished units usually carry a limited warranty of 90 days to one year.

Risk level: Scratch and dent carries the lowest risk since the units are mechanically new. Open box is low to moderate. Refurbished carries the highest risk because the unit was previously faulty.

Which One Should You Choose?

Choose scratch and dent if you want the best combination of savings, quality, and warranty protection. You’re buying a new appliance at a used-appliance price, with the peace of mind that comes from knowing nothing mechanical has ever gone wrong.

Choose open box if cosmetic appearance matters to you and you’re okay with a smaller discount. Open-box units often look pristine.

Choose refurbished if price is your primary concern and you’re comfortable with more uncertainty. Stick with manufacturer-certified refurbished programs to minimize risk.

A Few Tips Regardless of What You Buy

No matter which category you choose, always inspect the appliance in person before paying. Ask about warranty coverage and get the terms in writing. Confirm the return policy. And research the model number to make sure it has the features, capacity, and dimensions you need.

Find Scratch & Dent Stores Near You

Browse our directory of 728+ verified stores across 51 states.